Sensual attraction, passion, niches, and why the erotic book market doesn't matter as much as your authentic and personal erotic libido
Rule #1: Write What Turns You On
Of all the things I learned from interviewing over thirty erotic authors, this is the one that came up time and again. In different words, but always with the same absolute conviction: the authors who thrive are the ones who write what genuinely ‘gets them off’.
Not what trends on Amazon.
Not what someone on a forum told them was going to sell.
They write what actually, personally, viscerally turns them on. It’s why I write in black lace top nylons, heels and black lace panties. For me, and for many of my kinky colleagues, the pleasure of the creative process is essential to the success of our stories.
Let me share their insights.
The Trap of Writing for the Market First
It’s tempting, when you first decide to write erotica, to approach it like any other commercial venture. You research the bestseller charts. You notice that stepbrother romance is outselling everything. You write a stepbrother romance even though you find the whole premise mildly baffling. The book is technically competent. It sells twelve copies. You give up.
This failed approach came up in several of my interviews. The authors who have succeeded were the ones who eventually stopped trying to second-guess the market and start writing the stories they actually wanted to read. Wanted to sensually consume themselves.
“Rule number one: write what interests you, not what you think other people will like. If you don’t enjoy the stories, writing will become really unpleasant.”
Ann Michelle, with over 60 No.1 bestselling forced feminisation titles to her name
Ann Michelle discovered her niche almost by necessity.
When she started looking for the kind of stories she wanted to read, intimate, nuanced forced feminisation with real warmth, she found almost nothing. Most of what existed was either too harsh, too soft, or didn’t feature actual feminisation at all.
So she wrote her own.
And in doing so she found her audience, because that audience had the same problem she had: they were searching for exactly the thing she was creating.
This is the magic of writing what you love in a niche genre. Your specificity is your superpower. The more precisely you write to your own desire, the more precisely you speak to the reader who shares it.
Your Kink Is Your Compass
Charlie Quinn, who writes every flavour of femdom imaginable, had a delightfully unplanned origin story.
She sat down to write a conventional piece of romantic erotica, a married couple having a rather civilised threesome, and the characters simply refused to cooperate. A side character took over. A powerful older woman started dominating everyone in sight.
Before Charlie knew it, she had written something gloriously kinky that she hadn’t planned at all, which deliciously reflected her own erotic experiences and desires far more honestly than her original outline had.
“It felt good to write it like that, and even though I didn’t feel it was very marketable, it reflected my own life experiences. So since then, it’s been femdom all the way!”
Charlie Quinn
“Follow your own kinks and write what you enjoy. As long as there’s consent, anything goes! There’s a place for all of us in this world, however non-conforming or wild our sex lives and fantasies are.”
Charlie Quinn
This is so important it bears repeating: she didn’t think it was marketable. She wrote it anyway because it felt right. And it found its readers.
Write With Authenticity That Readers Can Feel, Sense, Smell, Lick, Stroke
There is something readers can detect in erotica that they cannot easily articulate but that they respond to powerfully: genuine sensual, erotic and sexual excitement in the author.
When an author is truly aroused by what they’re writing, it comes through on the page.
The scenes have heat.
The characters have vivid lives.
The details are juicy, not just technically accurate in a creative writing sense, but emotionally true in the way that only lived desire can produce.
“You shouldn’t just write only what you think your audience wants. There has to be some of you in there, too. If you aren’t interested in what you’re saying, nobody else will be.”
Madeline Dusk, bestselling futa erotica author
Madeline discovered her niche – futa erotica – after a year of writing stories “all over the place” that got polite responses but never built a readership.
She was about to quit when she tried one more subgenre, almost on a whim. Something clicked in her kinky soul.
The stories felt right to write.
The readers came.
She now has well over a hundred titles to her name.
“I couldn’t find anything that tickled me just the way I wanted, so I decided to write my own. I was (and continue to be!) headstrong enough to believe that if I was looking for it, someone else probably was too.”
Vanessa Lockridge, transgender romance and feminisation author
Vanessa’s logic is the logic of every great niche creator: if you are searching for something and it doesn’t exist, you are probably not alone. Write the thing you cannot find. Become the author you wished existed.
Finding Your Niche: It’s More Specific Than You Think
One of the most striking things about the authors I interviewed was the specificity of their niches. Not just “erotica.” Not even “femdom erotica.” But highly particular corners of the erotic imagination. And within those corners, an even more specific emotional flavour.
Lady Alexa, for instance, doesn’t just write female-led relationships. She writes real, lived FLR stories from inside a genuine lifestyle, Her writing has a very specific sensibility around forced feminisation, humiliation, and the particular textures of domestic power exchange. That specificity, rooted in authentic experience, is what makes her work distinctive.
“I love to write about strong alpha women who force men to submit to them, especially to being feminised. I will often make the submissive male the protagonist in my stories but there will always be an extreme version of me in the story making things happen.”
Lady Alexa
Alison Osias writes fantasy erotica featuring size play, monster girls, and femdom, a very particular flavour of wholesome-but-kinky adventure that is entirely her own.
She came to it through years of text-based roleplay in the World of Warcraft community, where she had already developed a strong sense of what excited her and what her fictional voice sounded like.
“I love to write fantasy stories in paradisal, happy spaces that nonetheless have their hint of mystery and adventure. I write about happy and wholesome characters that get into surprisingly kinky fun together.”
Alison Osias
The word “wholesome” in the context of erotic fantasy might raise an eyebrow, but that is precisely the point. Alison’s particular blend of warmth, adventure, and kink is hers alone. You can feel her genuine delight in every story.
When You Love It, the Words Cum Fast and Easy
Milfy Erotica described the moment she rediscovered writing erotica after a long hiatus with the kind of vivid pleasure that no amount of commercial calculation could produce:
“The words flowed out of me and I loved every second of being behind the laptop, letting my fingers type out all the ideas I had locked in my head all these years.”
Milfy Erotica
That is the feeling you are looking for. When writing feels like release rather than labour. When the scenes come to you in the shower, on walks, at 2am. Not because you’re grinding through a deadline but because the story is alive and wants to be told.
Keary Hayes puts it with admirable clarity and a lovely lack of pretension:
“Write what you love. Chances are you’ll never be ‘rich’, but if you love what you write you’ll have enjoyed every step of the journey.”
Keary Hayes
But Wait, Does the Market Not Matter At All?
Yes, of course the market matters.
You need readers, and readers have preferences.
Several authors did note the importance of understanding what your audience wants, particularly once you have an established readership and are deciding whether to branch out or stay in your lane.
But the consensus, strongly, is that market research comes second.
You find your niche by following your passion, not by following a spreadsheet. Once you have found your niche and your voice, then you can start being strategic about how you serve your readers within it.
“I actually like variety. I don’t want to do one thing over and over. So I’ve done everything from dominant wives to mousy wives to secretaries to guys who trap themselves, to more fantastic things like secret schools.”
Ann Michelle
Even within a niche, Ann gives herself creative room to play. The niche (intimate forced feminisation) is consistent; the stories within it are endlessly varied. That is the sweet spot: committed to what excites you, inventive in how you express it.
The Bottom Line: What This Means for You
- Don’t start from the bestseller chart. Start from your own kinky, insatiable, perhaps even unspeakable desires.
- The gap between what you want to read and what exists is where your career lives.
- Specificity is not a limitation, it is your competitive advantage.
- If writing feels like a grind from day one, you’re probably writing the wrong stories.
- Market awareness is useful once you’ve found your voice. Not before.
- Follow the heat. You’ll know it when you feel it. It will make your naughty bits tingle and dampen.
Ready for the next step? Read Rule #2: Tell Your Truth — and see how real reader emails can transform an author’s day. Or explore the community Jenny writes for in the 2025 Crossdresser Community Survey.
The Complete Guide: All Ten Posts
- Introduction to the series.
Where the data came from and what you can learn as erotic author. - Rule #1 Write What Makes YOU Hot
On passion, niches, and why following your own desire is the only reliable compass. - Rule #2 Write Your Truth
And How One Reader Email Can Change Your Whole Day, Or Your Whole Life.
This list will be updated as new posts go online.
I live for all things feminine—stockings, heels, scarlet nails, and above all, the intoxicating touch of another woman. A translesbian muse and unapologetic hedonist, I share my most divine and wicked misadventures in words and now as a podcaster too. All gurls welcome. You are gorgeous. Just like me. xxx
Goodreads // Amazon Author Page
